What Happens If You Use the Wrong Oil Grade in Your Engine?

ALTERNATIVE AUTOMOTIVE • July 16, 2025

We get it—oil is oil, right? Not quite. Using the wrong oil grade in your engine can lead to some serious trouble down the road. That number on the oil bottle actually matters, and your car’s performance (and lifespan) depends on getting it right.


So, What Is Oil Grade Anyway?

When you see something like 5W-30 on a bottle, it’s not just alphabet soup. That code tells you how the oil performs in different temperatures. The first number (with the “W” for winter) shows how it flows when it’s cold. The second number is how it holds up when your engine’s running hot.


What Can Go Wrong With the Wrong Oil?

Here’s what you might run into if you use the wrong oil:

Golden motor oil pouring from a bottle.
  • Poor Lubrication – Thicker oil may not reach tight engine areas, while thinner oil might not protect as well under heat and stress. Either way, your engine parts are grinding more than they should.
  • Increased Wear & Tear – Your engine’s parts are designed with specific tolerances. The wrong oil breaks that balance, speeding up wear.
  • Reduced Fuel Efficiency – The engine works harder to move too-thick oil or doesn’t run optimally with too-thin oil. Either way, you’ll feel it at the pump.
  • Engine Overheating or Failure Without proper oil flow and protection, your engine can overheat or even seize up. And trust us, that’s not cheap to fix.


What Should You Do?

Check your owner’s manual for the recommended oil grade. And when in doubt, let us handle it. At Alternative Automotive, we use the right oil, every time. Whether it’s a routine change or you’re not sure what your car needs, we’ve got your back.

Oil Change
Santa Claus in red car, waving, wearing sunglasses.
By Alternative Automotive December 17, 2025
December driving in Missouri brings frost, road trips, and winter hazards. Get simple tips to keep your car safe, reliable, and road-ready all month long.
The crew at Altenative Automotive
By Alternative Automotive December 2, 2025
As the year winds down and the holiday lights start popping up around Winfield, we can’t help but feel incredibly grateful.
Document titled
By Alternative Automotive November 17, 2025
What does a powertrain warranty really cover? It's less than you think. Find out the truth about your engine, transmission, and drivetrain coverage before you need a repair.
White SUV parked on a leaf-covered path in a forest with autumn foliage.
By Alternative Automotive November 6, 2025
Experience the best of Missouri in fall! Scenic drives, state parks, and colorful foliage—get your car ready for the ultimate autumn adventure.
Car insurance form with a toy car, cash, and a pen on a table.
By Alternative Automotive October 14, 2025
Car insurance is designed to help when the unexpected happens.
A Dummy’s Guide to Jumpstarting Your Car (Without Looking Like One) blog
By Alternative Automotive October 1, 2025
We’ve all been there: you hop in the car, turn the key, and click… nothing. Your battery’s dead. But don’t panic (and definitely don’t call your cousin who “knows cars” but once put diesel in a gas tank). Here’s the simple, funny-but-true guide to jumpstarting your car—so you look like a pro, not a dummy.
Two women in a truck bed, waving foam fingers, cheering at a tailgate party. Red and white theme.
By Alternative Automotive September 17, 2025
Fall in Missouri means one thing—football season.
Road through trees with red and orange autumn foliage. Wet asphalt with fallen leaves.
By Alternative Automotive September 4, 2025
Driving on Missouri’s scenic fall roads? Wet leaves can be as dangerous as black ice—hiding potholes, reducing traction, and even causing car damage. Learn how to stay safe and protect your vehicle this autumn.
Brakes
By Alternative Automotive August 20, 2025
At Alternative Automotive, we’re all about helping you get the most out of your vehicle, and that starts with staying on top of the essentials.
Person's hand wearing an oven mitt on a car steering wheel; orange mitt, black wheel.
By Alternative Automotive August 5, 2025
We know the heat is rough, but car trouble during a heat wave is worse. Swing by Alternative Automotive and we’ll make sure your vehicle is ready to handle this Missouri summer like a pro.
More Posts